On Freedom Boulevard in Provo, Utah, nestled between the mountains of Uinta National Forest and Lake Utah is a nice little one-branch bank, pictured above. It looks innocent enough. Its CEO, Doug Christensen, invites personal emails from his home page. Ping him quickly, as I assume he's soon out of a job.
The Federal Reserve last week approved prepaid debit card provider Green Dot to purchase the bank, thereby becoming a bank holding company. The bank is tiny, with less than $40 million in assets. If the filings from last March are any indication, the purchase price was around $15 million with an additional $10 million contribution to core deposits. What's the big deal? I'm not sure, honestly.
It's the first pure prepaid program manager to own a bank. It will give Green Dot greater control over its destiny. Instead of asking for approval from a partnering bank for anything new they might want to do, they can instead ask their regulators directly. Presumably this is better. We'll see, since the regulatory environment doesn't look favorably on prepaid or many forms of adventurous consumer finance (mostly not for good reasons, to this observer).
Control to what end? I'll join the speculators who assume some kind of savings product offered through the prepaid account. Presumably some kind of "real" account that's functionally the same as prepaid, but can be marketed differently and avoid the negative stigma associated with the word "prepaid" for many. Perhaps BIN sponsorship to other program managers, much like the Green Dot Money Pack allows cash loads for cards by third parties, like American Express, Plastyc and many others. Perhaps additional transaction products, like bill pay and money transfer, that can take advantage of a national bank charter without needing to register as Money Services Business in most states. I'd love to see credit products, but Green Dot's CEO, Steve Streit, has never been a fan. Without credit, it seems like a bank charter is underutilized.
Beyond control, owning a bank will provide some economic efficiency. When Green Dot has transitioned its customers from its current banks in 18 months, it will no longer have to pay a third party a fractional amount of interchange and regular account fees. At scale this is undoubtedly a big number, but it comes with a real cost: not just a public company, but now a bank, Green Dot will have real costs associated with regulatory compliance.
I'm sure they've done the math, but given what a commodity BIN sponsorship is these days, the economic advantage isn't overwhelmingly clear to me. The move certainly steers Green Dot clear of Durban-inspired debit card fees, since banks smaller than $10b are exempt.
Given that Wal-Mart has a stake in Green Dot, I wonder if the move might bolster a renewed application for a bank purchase by the retail giant. It tried and failed several years ago, thwarted by the small bankers association. Perhaps this transaction offers a precedent.
While it's a big move, and one that sets the stage for an expanded universe of players serving the underbanked with greater scale and efficiency, I lack the insight or imagination to be blown away. I assume I'll be proven wrong.
417
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show417_thumb5898.jpg
TD Bank goes net zero energy
TD Bank goes net zero energy
407
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show407_thumb5665.jpg
ATM fee disclosure stickers
ATM fee disclosure stickers
387
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show387_thumb5320.png
GetBranded ATM wraps
GetBranded ATM wraps
376
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show376_thumb5045.jpg
Express Teller Services ATM surround installations
Express Teller Services ATM surround installations
373
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show373_thumb4988.jpg
GRG Banking Vietnam Day
GRG Banking Vietnam Day
346
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show346_thumb4575.png
ATMequipment.com at the ATMIA Show 2011
ATMequipment.com at the ATMIA Show 2011
347
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show347_thumb4583.png
Opt Connect at the ATMIA Show 2011
Opt Connect at the ATMIA Show 2011
345
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show345_thumb4569.jpg
Diebold ATM is the centerpiece of international art exhibit
Diebold ATM is the centerpiece of international art exhibit
336
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show336_thumb4475.jpg
Talaris Ltd.
Talaris Ltd.
332
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/slideshows/show332_thumb4431.jpg
Itautec displays cash dispenser and deposit-taking ATMs
Itautec displays cash dispenser and deposit-taking ATMs
PAI Kiosk Solutions
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4666.png
4666/PAI-Kiosk-Solutions
V4500 Enterprise Class Router: Best-in-Class Connectivity
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4380.png
4380/V4500-Enterprise-Class-Router-Best-in-Class-Connectivity
Refurbished ATMs
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/Refurbished_ATMs_100.gif
1174/Refurbished-ATMs
RL2000 — Retail ATM
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/RL2000_100.gif
1019/RL2000-Retail-ATM
Merchant/ Retail Chain Solutions
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/Retail_Sol_100.gif
1191/Merchant-Retail-Chain-Solutions
ATM Security
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4428.png
4428/ATM-Security
V1000 M2M Router – Cost-Effective Wireless Gateway
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4364.png
4364/V1000-M2M-Router-Cost-Effective-Wireless-Gateway
OptiVault
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/Optivaultlogo100.jpg
462/OptiVault
ATM and Financial Self-Service Device Connectivity – JAM SI
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/LogoJAMSI.gif
3744/ATM-and-Financial-Self-Service-Device-Connectivity-JAM-SI
Data Replay Tool (DART™)
http://global.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4259.png
4259/Data-Replay-Tool-DART
|
Inside NetWorld Alliance Network Self-Service World
|
Popular on NetWorld Alliance | Other NetWorld Alliance Sites | Global Partners |